Tampa Bay Lightning @ New York Islanders
Sat Oct 10, 7:40 PM ET
More
Odds from the latest scan: October 9, 1:49 PM ET. Live odds for this game.
Fanatics pays the most on Tampa Bay Lightning at -155, and Polymarket US pays the most on New York Islanders at +140. Across the 10 books pricing this game the best and worst numbers are $10.00 apart on a $100 bet.
Best NHL price on Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders, compared across every major US sportsbook plus Kalshi, Polymarket US, ProphetX and Novig. Sat Oct 10, 7:40 PM ET.
Games starting within 24 hours refresh every minute; later games every 30 minutes and every hour as kickoff approaches during the beta; the free board refreshes hourly.
Moneyline Line HistoryTampa Bay Lightning -155 Fanatics·New York Islanders +140 Polymarket US
Every Book's Moneyline
| Book | Tampa Bay Lightning | New York Islanders |
|---|---|---|
| Polymarket US | -168 | +140 |
| Kalshi | -167 | +139 |
| Novig | -174 | +138 |
| DraftKings | -162 | +136 |
| LowVig | -155 | +136 |
| BetOnline | -155 | +136 |
| BetMGM | -160 | +135 |
| Bally Bet | -162 | +135 |
| BetRivers | -162 | +135 |
| BetParx | -162 | +135 |
| Caesars | -159 | +134 |
| Fanatics | -155 | +130 |
Spread Line HistoryTampa Bay Lightning -1.5 (+160) DraftKings·New York Islanders +1.5 (-180) BetMGM
Total Line HistoryOver 5.5 (-120) Fanatics·Under 5.5 (+102) DraftKings
About These Charts
Player Props
12 books priced this game. Prediction market prices include trading fees wherever a fee applies, so they are directly comparable to sportsbook lines.
On Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders, the best available price is not the same at every book. One sportsbook might post a side at -110 while another has it at -102, and taking the better number is the one edge you fully control. The Odds Gap scans every major US sportsbook plus the federally regulated prediction markets and flags where the best price sits on each side of this NHL matchup.
How to Read These Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders Odds
The cards above show the best moneyline price on each side and which book has it. The spread line shows New York Islanders at the market's consensus number, priced at the best odds among books quoting it. The total shows the Over at the consensus number. For every book's price on every market, open the game in the Line Shop.
What the Price Gap Is Worth
Across the 10 books quoting this side, the best price is +140 at Polymarket US and the worst is +130 at Fanatics. Same bet, same outcome, $10.00 difference in profit on a $100 stake. Nothing about the wager changes, only where you place it.
- Tampa Bay Lightning: best -155 (Fanatics), worst -174 (Novig)
- New York Islanders: best +140 (Polymarket US), worst +130 (Fanatics)
Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders Odds: Common Questions
Who has the best odds on Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders?
At the latest scan Fanatics pays the most on Tampa Bay Lightning at -155, and Polymarket US pays the most on New York Islanders at +140. Those are two different books more often than not, and the best number moves as books reprice, so check the table on this page before you bet rather than assuming one book wins both sides.
How much does the price differ between sportsbooks on this game?
Right now 10 books price this side, and the spread between the best and worst of them is +140 at Polymarket US versus +130 at Fanatics. On a $100 bet that is $10.00 more in your pocket for the same wager, won or lost the same way. That difference is the entire reason this page exists.
What is the spread and total for Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders?
The consensus spread is +1.5 on New York Islanders with the best juice at -180 (BetMGM), and the consensus total is 5.5 with the best Over price at -120 (Fanatics). Consensus means the line most books agree on; the flagged price is the best juice available at that same number.
How often do these NHL odds update?
The free board rescans every hour from 7am to 1am ET; Live Beta, free with an email signup during the beta, refreshes every minute. This page was last scanned October 9, 1:49 PM ET, and that timestamp is shown above the table.
Does The Odds Gap pick a side on Tampa Bay Lightning vs New York Islanders?
No. There is no model, no projection, and no lean anywhere on this site. We show which book pays the most on a bet you have already decided to make. Math, not picks.
The Rest Of This NHL Slate
- Philadelphia Flyers vs Boston Bruins odds · Sat Oct 10, 1:10 PM ET
- Vancouver Canucks vs New Jersey Devils odds · Sat Oct 10, 3:40 PM ET
- Edmonton Oilers vs San Jose Sharks odds · Sat Oct 10, 4:10 PM ET
- Minnesota Wild vs Florida Panthers odds · Sat Oct 10, 6:10 PM ET
- Columbus Blue Jackets vs St Louis Blues odds · Sat Oct 10, 7:10 PM ET
The Odds Gap Daily
One email each morning with the biggest gaps on the board.
Looking for live prices? Use Unlock Live at the top of the page.