New York Islanders @ Toronto Maple Leafs
Final October 17, 2026 · 7:15 PM ET
Final: New York Islanders 4, Toronto Maple Leafs 1.
How the Odds Moved, Open to Final
Pinnacle's moneyline, from the first price we saw on Oct 16 to the final whistle.
Pinnacle is the reference line, never a price to bet at here.
About This Chart
Live prices are checked every minute and stored when the price, a line or the inning changes, so readings here are about 5 minutes apart. The longest gap between readings in this game is 6 minutes.
Pinnacle's moneyline from the first price we captured on Oct 16 to the end of the game: 25 pregame readings, then 33 in-game readings over 147 minutes. The dashed line is puck drop. The pregame side is drawn on a shorter time scale than the game so the game gets most of the width. Plotted as win probability with the vig removed, so the two sides sum to 100%. Pinnacle is the reference market because it prices every game before and during play, and one book keeps the line continuous. It is not a US-licensed book and is never shown as a best price here. Hover or press the chart for the American price at any moment. The Spread and Total views draw Pinnacle's main line at each reading as a step, so every move from one number to the next shows where it happened, with the prices in the readout. A team we have no colour on record for is drawn in a site colour.
Earliest at Pinnacle: the Maple Leafs -135 on Oct 16, closed at -123.
Where Pinnacle's Line Opened, and Where It Closed
This game was listed before Pinnacle priced it, so the number below is Pinnacle's earliest price on it rather than the first number anyone posted. It was actually posted, it is stamped with its own time, and the market may already have moved before it existed.
- New York Islanders: PINN open +120, closed +112 (shorter)
- Toronto Maple Leafs: PINN open -135, closed -123 (longer)
Bally Bet paid the most on the Islanders at +114. $100 there made $10.00 more than at Kalshi (+104).
Closing Prices 13 Books
Closing prices as of October 17, 7:12 PM ET. These do not move again.
Closing Moneyline
| Book | New York Islanders | Toronto Maple Leafs |
|---|---|---|
 Novig | +113 | -117 |
 ProphetX | +111 | -121 |
 Bally Bet | +114 | -136 |
 BetParx | +114 | -136 |
 DraftKings | +110 | -130 |
 Fanatics | +110 | -130 |
 theScore Bet | +110 | -130 |
 Polymarket US | +105 | -125 |
 FanDuel | +105 | -126 |
 Kalshi | +104 | -125 |
 BetMGM | +105 | -130 |
 Caesars | +106 | -132 |
 Hard Rock Bet | +110 | -140 |
 BetOnline | +109 | -123 |
 LowVig | +109 | -123 |
 Bovada | +110 | -130 |
 Fliff | +110 | -135 |
 MyBookie | +108 | -132 |
Closing Spread best flagged at +1.5 / -1.5
| Book | New York Islanders | Toronto Maple Leafs |
|---|---|---|
| Novig | +1.5 -228 | -1.5 +203 |
| ProphetX | +1.5 -240 | -1.5 +201 |
| DraftKings | +1.5 -225 | -1.5 +185 |
| Kalshi | +1.5 -250 | -1.5 +189 |
| FanDuel | +1.5 -235 | -1.5 +186 |
| Fanatics | +1.5 -235 | -1.5 +185 |
| BetMGM | +1.5 -220 | -1.5 +180 |
| Polymarket US | +1.5 -229 | -1.5 +181 |
| theScore Bet | +1.5 -225 | -1.5 +180 |
| Bally Bet | +1.5 -235 | -1.5 +180 |
| BetParx | +1.5 -235 | -1.5 +180 |
| Hard Rock Bet | +1.5 -230 | -1.5 +175 |
| Bovada | +1.5 -230 | -1.5 +190 |
| BetOnline | +1.5 -225 | -1.5 +189 |
| LowVig | +1.5 -225 | -1.5 +189 |
| MyBookie | +1.5 -222 | -1.5 +178 |
| Fliff | +1.5 -245 | -1.5 +180 |
Closing Total best flagged at 6.5
| Book | Over | Under |
|---|---|---|
| Novig | 6.5 +108 | 6.5 -122 |
| DraftKings | 6.5 +105 | 6.5 -125 |
| Fanatics | 6.5 +105 | 6.5 -125 |
| theScore Bet | 6.5 +105 | 6.5 -125 |
| Polymarket US | 6.5 +105 | 6.5 -125 |
| ProphetX | 6.5 +103 | 6.5 -124 |
| Hard Rock Bet | 6.5 +100 | 6.5 -120 |
| BetMGM | 6.5 +100 | 6.5 -120 |
| FanDuel | 6.5 +104 | 6.5 -128 |
| Bally Bet | 6.5 +105 | 6.5 -130 |
| BetParx | 6.5 +105 | 6.5 -130 |
| Kalshi | 6.5 +100 | 6.5 -130 |
| Caesars | 6 -125 | 6 +100 |
| Fliff | 6.5 +100 | 6.5 -130 |
| BetOnline | 6 -121 | 6 +105 |
| LowVig | 6 -121 | 6 +105 |
| Bovada | 6 -125 | 6 +105 |
| MyBookie | 6 -121 | 6 -101 |
Previous Meetings
- Sep 30, 2026: New York Islanders 1, Toronto Maple Leafs 2 · closing moneyline +125 / -135
Next Up For Toronto Maple Leafs
- Toronto Maple Leafs: Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs odds · Tue Nov 10, 7:10 PM ET
NHL Games Coming Up
- Minnesota Wild vs Montréal Canadiens odds · Tue Nov 10, 7:10 PM ET
- New Jersey Devils vs Winnipeg Jets odds · Tue Nov 10, 7:10 PM ET
- Washington Capitals vs Ottawa Senators odds · Tue Nov 10, 7:10 PM ET
- Colorado Avalanche vs Toronto Maple Leafs odds · Tue Nov 10, 7:10 PM ET
- Florida Panthers vs Columbus Blue Jackets odds · Tue Nov 10, 7:40 PM ET
Trends for This Game
About This Page
Prices are from our latest scan of every major US sportsbook and exchange, with the time shown on the card.
Best price means the most you can get paid. Offshore books and Pinnacle are never counted as best.
Exchange prices include their fees.
The Line History chart shows every scan since the game was posted.
Information only, not betting advice. 21+ only.
About These Closing Odds
Every price on this page is a book's own last quote strictly before New York Islanders and Toronto Maple Leafs started, taken from our scan archive. A book that stopped pricing the game early still shows the number it closed at, and a book that never priced it is not listed. 19 books priced this game. The tables list the books you can bet; an offshore book shows when you turn it on in your books, and Pinnacle appears only as the reference on the chart. Prediction market prices include trading fees wherever a fee applies, so they are directly comparable to sportsbook lines. See how we calculate this.
This page is permanent. The closing prices above do not change again, and the page keeps them at this address after the game, the season and the rematch, so it stays a citable record of what this line actually closed at.
Cite this page: https://theoddsgap.com/odds/nhl/new-york-islanders-vs-toronto-maple-leafs, final October 17, 2026.
The Odds Gap Daily
One email each morning: how the lines moved in last night's big game, new finds from Trends, and where the books disagree most on the weekend slate.
Looking for live prices? Use Unlock Live at the top of the page.
