New York Red Bulls @ New York City FC
Fri Sep 18, 7:30 PM ET
More
Odds from the latest scan: September 13, 1:13 AM ET. Live odds for this game.
Pinnacle pays the most on New York Red Bulls at +283, and Hard Rock Bet pays the most on New York City FC at -115. Across the 11 books pricing this game the best and worst numbers are $33.00 apart on a $100 bet.
Best MLS price on New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC, compared across every major US sportsbook plus Kalshi and Novig. Fri Sep 18, 7:30 PM ET.
Games starting within 24 hours refresh every minute; later games every 30 minutes and every hour as kickoff approaches during the beta; the free board refreshes hourly.
Moneyline Line HistoryNew York Red Bulls +283 Pinnacle·Draw +320 BetOnline·New York City FC -115 Hard Rock Bet
Every Book's Moneyline
| Book | New York Red Bulls | New York City FC |
|---|---|---|
| Hard Rock Bet | +250 | -115 |
| BetParx | +250 | -117 |
| Bally Bet | +250 | -117 |
| BetRivers | +250 | -117 |
| Fanatics | +280 | -120 |
| Pinnacle | +283 | -122 |
| BetOnline | +282 | -122 |
| LowVig | +282 | -122 |
| BetMGM | +280 | -125 |
| Novig | +251 | -125 |
| MyBookie | +270 | -126 |
Total Line History
About These Charts
11 books priced this game. Prediction market prices include trading fees wherever a fee applies, so they are directly comparable to sportsbook lines.
On New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC, the best available price is not the same at every book. One sportsbook might post a side at -110 while another has it at -102, and taking the better number is the one edge you fully control. The Odds Gap scans every major US sportsbook plus the federally regulated prediction markets and flags where the best price sits on each side of this MLS matchup.
How to read these New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC odds
Soccer is a 3-way market, so there are three prices: New York Red Bulls to win, the draw, or New York City FC to win. Each card above shows the single best available number on that outcome and which book or exchange has it. For every book's price on the match, open it in the MLS board or the Line Shop.
What the Price Gap Is Worth
Across the 11 books quoting this side, the best price is +283 at Pinnacle and the worst is +250 at BetParx. Same bet, same outcome, $33.00 difference in profit on a $100 stake. Nothing about the wager changes, only where you place it.
- New York Red Bulls: best +283 (Pinnacle), worst +250 (BetParx)
- New York City FC: best -115 (Hard Rock Bet), worst -126 (MyBookie)
Where Pinnacle's Line Opened
This game was listed before Pinnacle priced it, so this is Pinnacle's earliest price on it rather than the first number anyone posted. It is stamped with its own time, it was actually posted, and the market may already have moved before it existed.
- New York City FC: PINN open -125, now -115 (10 cents longer)
- New York Red Bulls: PINN open +277, now +283 (6 cents longer)
The charts above plot every scan since, so you can see whether the move came in one step or drifted.
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC Odds: Common Questions
Who has the best odds on New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?
At the latest scan Pinnacle pays the most on New York Red Bulls at +283, and Hard Rock Bet pays the most on New York City FC at -115. Those are two different books more often than not, and the best number moves as books reprice, so check the table on this page before you bet rather than assuming one book wins both sides.
How much does the price differ between sportsbooks on this game?
Right now 11 books price this side, and the spread between the best and worst of them is +283 at Pinnacle versus +250 at BetParx. On a $100 bet that is $33.00 more in your pocket for the same wager, won or lost the same way. That difference is the entire reason this page exists.
Where did the New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC line open?
New York City FC opened -125 at Pinnacle and is -115 now. We capture the opener once from the historical archive rather than inferring it, so the number on this page is the price that was actually posted, and the movement charts above plot every scan since.
What is the spread and total for New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?
The consensus spread is -0.5 on New York City FC with the best juice at -121 (Pinnacle), and the consensus total is 3.5 with the best Over price at +116 (MyBookie). Consensus means the line most books agree on; the flagged price is the best juice available at that same number.
How often do these MLS odds update?
The free board rescans every hour from 7am to 1am ET; Live Beta, free with an email signup during the beta, refreshes every minute. This page was last scanned September 13, 1:13 AM ET, and that timestamp is shown above the table.
Does The Odds Gap pick a side on New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?
No. There is no model, no projection, and no lean anywhere on this site. We show which book pays the most on a bet you have already decided to make. Math, not picks.
MLS Games Coming Up
- New England Revolution vs Chicago Fire odds · Sun Sep 13, 5:30 PM ET
- Austin FC vs Vancouver Whitecaps FC odds · Sun Sep 13, 6:30 PM ET
- Philadelphia Union vs San Diego FC odds · Sun Sep 13, 9:00 PM ET
- Columbus Crew SC vs CF Montreal odds · Sat Sep 19, 7:30 PM ET
- Los Angeles FC vs San Jose Earthquakes odds · Sat Sep 19, 7:30 PM ET
The Odds Gap Daily
One email each morning with the biggest gaps on the board.
Looking for live prices? Use Unlock Live at the top of the page.